Help Us Reach our Fiscal Year-End Goal
Make your gift to the Law Center while your gift will be matched, up to $15,000 before the end of our fiscal year.
Make your gift to the Law Center while your gift will be matched, up to $15,000 before the end of our fiscal year.
The House-passed bill to repeal the Affordable Care Act (ACA), the American Health Care Act (AHCA), threatens access to affordable health insurance coverage for survivors of domestic violence and sexual assault. The bill effectively prices survivors out of the individual health insurance market and leaves them without adequate health coverage necessary to meet particular health needs. The ACA repeal bill would either deter survivors from seeking or receiving the treatment that they need to recover and live healthy lives or force them to pay more for health insurance coverage, which could harm their wellbeing and economic security.
Here is how the ACA repeal bill jeopardizes access to health care for survivors of domestic violence and sexual assault:
But the ACA repeal bill would undo that critical protection. The term “health status’’ is not defined in the ACA repeal bill, and could include almost anything, ranging from medical history, to claims experience, to receipt of health care, to genetic information, to evidence of insurability.
Supporters of the ACA repeal bill claim that survivors of domestic violence are protected because the bill retains a portion of the ACA that prohibits insurers from considering “conditions arising out of acts of domestic violence” in determining evidence of insurability. But this protection is not enough to ensure survivors of domestic violence are treated fairly in the insurance market. For example, if a survivor of domestic violence needs treatment for injuries, but doesn’t report that the injury is due to domestic violence (because many survivors don’t, for good reason), then she could still face health status underwriting because of her medical treatment. What survivors need is what the ACA currently provides: specific protection related to domestic violence and the general health status underwriting prohibition. And of course the provision on domestic violence does not reach survivors of sexual assault, so they are without any protections at all in the ACA Repeal bill.
If the drafters of the ACA repeal bill had women’s needs in mind, and wanted to guarantee access to affordable health coverage for survivors of sexual assault or domestic violence, they certainly could have done so through several means, including preserving the ACA’s prohibition on health insurance underwriting. However, they did not, and as a result, survivors of sexual assault or domestic violence are vulnerable to discriminatory practices that were prevalent pre-ACA, which effectively priced many out of the private insurance market and deterred many from seeking the treatment that they need.
Supporters of the ACA repeal bill claim that state laws offer protections to survivors of domestic violence or sexual assault that ensure them access to coverage if federal law does not. It is true that the vast majority of states have laws that offer some protections in this area. But each law varies – whether it reaches sexual assault and/or domestic violence (most specifically protect only domestic violence survivors); whether it prohibits denials of coverage and/or charging more for coverage; whether there are other barriers in place in order to take advantage of the law’s protections. This patchwork of state laws does not in any way provide the assurances against insurance company discrimination for survivors of domestic violence and sexual assault that the ACA guarantees. And of course in states without such laws, survivors are left wholly unprotected.
This is the bottom line—without all of the protections put into place by the ACA, survivors of domestic violence and sexual assault are at the mercy of insurance companies and states. The ACA repeal bill disregards the past history that states and insurance companies often left survivors of domestic violence and sexual assault Nowhere to Turn for coverage in the individual health insurance market.