NWLC Warns St Mary SCOTUS Case Could Permit Discrimination Against Children of Same-Sex Couples and Undermine Universal Preschool Programs

WASHINGTON D.C. – On Nov. 3, 2026, the U.S. Supreme Court will hear oral arguments in St. Mary Catholic Parish in Littleton v. Roy, a case that challenges whether faith-based preschool providers receiving state funding under Colorado’s Universal Pre-K Program are bound by the program’s nondiscrimination requirements. Two Catholic parishes argue that nondiscrimination requirements burden their religious practice because they would not be able to receive state subsidies to operate their preschool programs while also turning away eligible four-year-old children of same-sex couples.

The National Women’s Law Center (NWLC) warns if the Supreme Court rules against Colorado’s nondiscrimination requirements, it could give an opening for other publicly funded programs–even those intended to promote universal access–to discriminate against people for a broad range of reasons, including sexual orientation.

“No four-year-old child should be denied preschool placement because their parents are gay or lesbian,” said Brian Dittmeier, director of LGBTQI+ equality at NWLC. “Marriage equality is the law of the land, and the Court should not open the door to extreme arguments that seek to chip away at equal rights for same-sex couples. All families deserve access to affordable, high-quality early care and education, which is exactly why Colorado voters mobilized to expand early education access in their state through this universal and incredibly successful program. 

“For years, Colorado’s faith-based preschools have had no trouble complying with nondiscrimination requirements as a common condition of receiving taxpayer funding to support their operations. Allowing discrimination in a state program specifically intended to achieve universal access is counter to Colorado voters’ intent and will leave same-sex families with fewer options to support their children. The same reasoning could later be used to turn away other children, including children of unmarried mothers or children whose parents are divorced. Such an outcome is unacceptable and will exacerbate the child care crisis in this country.”  

In Aug. 2026, NWLC filed an amicus brief with the Supreme Court arguing that universal access to child care and early education must mean universal for all children, including those with same-sex parents.