NWLC: Texas Allowed to to Sidestep Pregnant Workers’ Rights

WASHINGTON — Yesterday, the full 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that Texas does not have to comply with the critical commonsense workplace protections and accommodations required under the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act (PWFA).

Here’s how Texas got here: The PWFA was included in a massive federal spending bill Congress passed in 2023. Texas challenged the measure, arguing it was passed improperly because some House members were not physically present in the chamber during the vote, violating the constitutional quorum clause. A federal district court agreed and ruled that PWFA could not be enforced against Texas. A divided panel of the 5th Circuit overturned that decision, but yesterday, the full appeals court sided with Texas.

This decision only applies to Texas and protections remain in place for private businesses or other public employers.

Gaylynn Burroughs, vice president for education and workplace justice at the National Women’s Law Center, which has long advocated for the passage and robust implementation of PWFA, issued the following statement after the ruling:

“Pregnant workers should never have to choose between their paycheck and their health and the health of their pregnancy, but that’s exactly the position Texas is putting its employees in. At a time when women across the country are being pushed out of the workforce and struggling to afford groceries, gas, and healthcare, the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act provides critical, commonsense protections that allow simple, reasonable workplace changes to ensure people can stay healthy and continue earning a living while keeping their health insurance.

“Instead of ensuring these protections, Texas actively advocated against this law that helps pregnant and postpartum women stay connected to the labor force. Only a few weeks ago voters nationwide sent a clear message that affordability and rising costs were their top priority, but this decision will only serve to increase economic uncertainty for women in Texas.

“While this decision directly impacts pregnant workers employed by the state, it does not change protections under the PWFA or prevent the law from being enforced against any other employer — including any other employer in Texas. But the 5th Circuit’s ruling opens the door to arguments by other states that they, too, could ask a court to allow them to avoid  providing simple, fair accommodations for pregnant employees.

“To be clear: The problem was never with the appropriations act. Texas never gave up a single dollar it received from the federal spending bill. Instead, it used the Constitution as a weapon to upend civil rights protections for women workers. And a federal court let it stand. NWLC will continue fighting for the rights of all pregnant workers and against the extreme right’s plan to keep women out of the workforce.”

###